Skip to main content

Table 7 Teachers’ overall attitudes towards emergency remote teaching (ERT) and its concomitant technology use as implied in the articles reviewed (categorised based on World Bank (2020)’s country classification by income)

From: The use of technology in higher education teaching by academics during the COVID-19 emergency remote teaching period: a systematic review

References

Context(s) of focus

Teacher participants’ overall attitudes towards ERT and its concomitant technology usea

Mostly negative

More negative

Mixed response

More positive

Mostly positive

Studies focussing on high-income countries/regions (11)

 Marshalsey and Sclater (2020)

Australia

  

x

  

 Hadar et al. (2021)

Israel

   

x

 

 Alqabbani et al. (2020)

Saudi Arabia

    

x

 Alsadoon and Turkestani (2020)

Saudi Arabia

x

    

 Bailey and Lee (2020)

South Korea

  

x

  

 Sales et al. (2020)

Spain

   

x

 

 Mideros (2020)

Trinidad and Tobago

   

x

 

 Eringfeld (2021)

United Kingdom

  

x

  

 Kidd and Murray (2020)

United Kingdom

   

x

 

 Watermeyer et al. (2021)

United Kingdom

 

x

   

 Cutri et al. (2020)

United States

  

x

  

Studies focussing on upper-middle-income countries/regions (10)

 Gao and Zhang (2020)

China (Mainland)

  

x

  

 Lu (2020)

China (Mainland)

   

x

 

 Ren (2020)

China (Mainland)

   

x

 

 Tang et al. (2020)

China (Mainland)

   

x

 

 Zeng (2020)

China (Mainland)

   

x

 

 Diningrat et al. (2020)

Indonesia

x

    

 Mouchantaf (2020)

Lebanon

  

x

  

 Khoza and Mpungose (2020)

South Africa

  

x

  

 Tanga et al. (2020)

South Africa

x

    

 Akyürek (2020)

Turkey

 

x

   

Studies focussing on lower-middle-income countries/regions (8)

 Ghounane (2020)

Algeria

 

x

   

 Khan et al. (2020)

Bangladesh

x

    

 Sobaih et al. (2020)

Egypt

 

x

   

 Dampson et al. (2020)

Ghana

 

x

   

 Gyampoh et al. (2020)

Ghana

  

x

  

 Joshi et al. (2020)

India

x

    

 Said et al. (2021)

Pakistan

 

x

   

 Callo and Yazon (2020)

Philippines

 

x

   

Studies focussing on multiple countries/regions (3)

 Scherer et al. (2021)

58 countries globally

  

x

  

 Tartavulea et al., 2020

13 European countries

  

x

  

 Tejedor et al. (2020)

Spain, Italy, and Ecuador

  

x

  

Total

5

7

11

8

1

Percentage of total

16%

22%

34%

25%

3%

  1. aWe categorise teachers’ attitudes as reported by each paper into five categories (namely ‘mostly negative’, ‘more negative’, ‘mixed response’, ‘more positive’, and ‘mostly positive’) by weighing the strength of evidence for both positive and negative attitudes of teachers reported in and/or inferred from each included study. For example, for teachers’ attitudes to be categorised as ‘mostly negative’, the paper has to (1) present strong evidence for negative attitudes from teachers’ reports of dissatisfaction and frustrations over the challenges in ERT, and any indication of concern and anxiety, and (2) present little or no evidence for positive attitudes which can be inferred from teachers’ expressions of satisfaction and awareness of benefits brought by ERT, and any indication of optimism and hope